|
My
wife Joan worked on the 91st floor of the
South Tower; while I worked on the
72nd floor of the north tower. We usually get into
work late (about 9am), but Joan had been
pushing me to get out the door earlier and I was quite
proud of myself that Tuesday when I succeeded. So as
luck would have it, we got in the building at
8:30, 15 minutes before the first
plane hit the building.
Going up in the elevator I decided that I would
take my laptop and work on
the 65th floor that day, where I had been helping another Port
Authority department. Normally, I get caught up in a discussion and it
takes me quite a while to get off 72; but not that
Tuesday. I made it down
to 65 just 5 minutes before the plane hit. That spontaneous decision got
me 7 floors further away from the impact point
and that much closer to the ground. Thank God
all the people I work with on 72 also made it out, so I
probably would have survived either way.
When the first plane hit the North Tower on about the 90th floor it was
nowhere near as dramatic as you would think on the
65th floor, just 25 floors down. There was a
definite explosion but it did not sound that
bad.
There was a big flash of light. The really scary part was how much the
building moved, and kept moving, for a long time
before re-stabilizing. At the same time we saw
out the window that flaming pieces of the building were
flying past the window. People on the floor were a
little confused, should we stay there or start
to evacuate. The Floor Wardens with their red hats
had not yet mobilized to give us instructions. They probably would have
suggested we stay in the hall and wait for an
announcement. My survivor instinct kicked in.
I screamed out at the top of my considerable lungs that
people should get to the stairs and then I did so.
We all filed down the stairs quite calmly. We also moved very fast,
because we were not slowed up by people coming
in from other floors until we had gotten down 30
floors or more. Some people were crying, some people
were tired and not in that good a shape, but
we all helped the weaker. There were several times
that 2 landings ahead of me were empty,
because I was helping a heavy woman named
Michele who was having trouble with her knees. No one pushed past,
no one yelled at us. Many people in the stairs with
me had been in the last
bombing, and they kept telling us this was
much better than that time. The lights were
on, the smoke was not so bad, the bomb was above, not below
us - of course we were going to make it out. It
wasn't until all the traffic on the stairs
stopped that people got panicky and started to yell,
but then a stop & go pattern developed and we were
calm again.
It was on the stairs that I started to worry a little about Joan in the
other tower. We started to
hear that a plane had hit the building, and I
wondered if it might not bounce into the other tower. I kept trying my
cell phone but it wouldn't work- no surprise.
I put the thought of her being hurt out of my
mind because it was only causing me trouble.
We kept walking down the stairs. The smoke was
acrid, for a brief moment I thought we may get
poisoned, that perhaps we were not yet safe, but that passed quickly
too.
Of course we were safe, we were near the ground (just 20 or so flights
to go).
We saw the first rescue worker coming up our stairway on the 17th floor.
I remember that because one woman said that
last time she first saw them on the 18th
floor. Their coming up slowed us down a little more, but we had
all the time in the world... When we were almost all
the way down we came upon a floor that had
water pouring out from under the door. This caused a
waterfall all the rest of the way down, there were several inches of
water on the floor, but it was passable and
did not slow us up much.
We came out on the mezzanine level, which is the ground floor street
level on the front of the building. In all it
took us about an hour to get down the stairs.
There was probably less than a half hour before the South
Tower would
collapse. The plaza was filled with burning debris, but it did not
look very bad. The lower level windows to West St
were completely blown out, but nothing looked
bad out in the street.
It was then; however, that the seriousness of the situation became
apparent. The police had panic in their voice.
They yelled at us with a real sense of urgency
to move. You very quickly realized you were not safe yet. I ran
to the first officer I saw and asked how 2 world
trade was because my wife worked there on the
91st floor. I saw his face and everything went out of
me at once; I could barely speak and I squeaked
"don't tell me, please, I don't want to know".
I asked how could both towers be bad and he
told me that a plane had hit each building. I knew instantly that it was
a terrorist attack. He asked to use my cell
phone and tried to call someone but it didn't
work so he gave it back. He then looked at me strangely and
said "look at my name badge, my name is Morse.
If I don't make it out alive get
in touch with my family, let them know how I died, and that I loved
them". I promised I would and
ran down the escalator- dead inside because
Joan could be dead, and scared because the whole building could fall any
minute if that officer was so worried.
At the lower level they routed us through the basement mall. It was a
surreal scene. It was completely empty except for a
few rescue workers, the lights were out, the
sprinklers were all going off and the floor was
flooded. I looked to the right, toward the south
tower, and did not see a single person moving.
There was nothing to do but get out and get to a
phone, call Joan's parents and see if she had called
in. I was not
accepting her death until it was real. To think of it crippled me, made
my heart race, my breathing rapid, and my head
clouded. I had to stop thinking, I had to get
out first and then find her later.
We ran down the corridor past the PATH train, the same way I left work
every day. I saw the doors on the North side
of the tower and the street there looked fine,
but they were making us go a different way. That door was
closer, but I decided to trust the police and so I
went up the escalator and out the door by
where the Borders bookstore was, the Northeast corner of the
complex. When we got outside they yelled for us to run, some stuff was
on the ground and I realized that I could
still be killed by falling debris.
They kept yelling "don't look up",
so I waited until I got across Church Street
next to the Millennium hotel before I turned around to see the fate of
the South Tower where Joan worked. That was when I
lost all hope; the second plane had hit the
building below Joan's floor. The flames
were leaping upward. She was in a towering
inferno in the worst possible place,
trapped above the flames.
My reactions at that moment in time are very strange to me. I thought I
would have fallen to the floor catatonic, or been incapable of
comprehending the information, but neither of those things happened.
Instead I focused on one thing, get to a phone, call Joan’s mother, and
see if she called in. In retrospect I chose to keep hope alive where
very little existed, to delay my breakdown until it was absolutely
justified, when it was certain she was dead. At that time I still did
not know that she had 18 minutes to get out. I heard that 2 planes hit,
the natural image I had formed was that they flew in formation and
struck simultaneously.
My
survival instincts were still very strong. I still did not feel safe
right across the street from the building, where so many people stopped
to watch. As I ran down the block next to the old church toward
Broadway I saw the looks of horror on the onlookers’ faces and I knew I
did not want to look back. I saw one policeman scream that another body
was falling and then quickly turn his head away. There was nothing I
wanted to see back in that building. Those were not images I could bear
to imprint on my memory cells so they could haunt me for decades to
come. I moved fast, searching only for a free phone.
Of
course every phone had a long line of people waiting, and I was brought
up too polite to push them aside. I felt their calls were as important
as mine, we all had just suffered incredibly horrible things. Besides,
never one to follow the crowd, I did not want to be herded with everyone
and never be able to get near a free phone. So I ran across Broadway
and up Fulton Street, dashing to some of the smaller side streets where
there were less people; always heading East, toward the other river.
Even on the back streets all the phones had lines. Inside, I thought,
would be available phones. Suddenly I saw a synagogue and ran inside.
There was a phone in the back I could use, the Rabbi told me. Shaking,
I ran back and waited a few minutes for the one other person who had
thought of using the phone to get finished. After a try or two I got
through to Joan’s family and found out that she was alive and had
already called in. Now all the emotions that were hiding inside me
broke out. My sister in law told me that I was laughing and crying at
the same time. I only remember such a
powerful, all- enveloping feeling of joy that seemed to rise right up
through my body and soar skyward, toward God who had answered the
prayers I had been saying as I ran along.
But my joy and feeling of safety vanished almost instantly. I made
another call, and as I was speaking to my father, letting him know we
were alive, I heard a horrible series of explosions and everyone
screaming in the street. By now we knew this was a terrorist attack and
so I thought they were bombing the city. I hung up on my father and ran
to the door. When I opened it there was only blackness and pandemonium,
everyone was running down the block to get away from the towers, and the
black cloud of dust that we now know was the pulverized building
completely filled the air.
The Rabbi told us we all had to leave the
building, that it was unsafe and might collapse. He led us all out, he
fighting through the dust at the head of the line of people. I was the
last to leave, trying to make one last call to Joan’s house to see if
she had called in again once the building fell. No calls would go
through, so I followed the others, letting the door close behind me.
As soon as I got outside I knew it was a mistake, the dust filled my
eyes, coated my mouth, suffocating me almost instantly. I turned and
tried to get back inside but the doors had locked. I pulled on each in
turn with no luck. Finally I used all my might and pulled again and the
lock gave way and the door flew open, I fell back inside to safety.
I then thought of the other people outside and reopened the door. Very
little of the dust came in; it seemed driven forward in a straight line,
not veering off to the sides where I peered out the door. I yelled for
people to come inside, and a few did, but most kept running, too panic
stricken to hear. The ones who came in were covered in gray ash; it was
piled 6” on their heads and shoulders and completely covered their
faces. I found a cup and water fountain and gave anyone who would take
it a glass of water, I found cloth and wet it so they could wash their
faces. One of the survivors had a portable radio and it told us the
tower had fell. At least it wasn’t another terrorist attack, but it
also told us there were 8 planes hijacked and only 4 accounted for. We
had not yet found safety. We then found out that the Pentagon had been
attacked and I knew at that moment that the way of life we had known was
gone, in a single second. There might never again be a place of safety.
I kept opening the door and trying to get people to come inside and
protect their lungs. Two rescue workers fell into the door, one so
overcome he could not get up. We wiped him off and gave him water and
he sat up and gathered himself together. Within minutes the two had
gone back out into the dust to save more lives. Unbelievably focused on
their jobs, unconcerned for their own safety. I felt like a coward,
holed up inside protecting myself, but I was again focused on only one
thing: Joan’s safety. |
|
I
kept calling the house, finally I got through. No, Joan had not called
back in once the tower fell. My heart sunk. They did not know where
she was when she first called in. I had time to call, why hadn’t she?
I had no idea that the tower had imploded, so I feared the building had
toppled and killed hundreds more. What if Joan was hanging around the
building looking for me? She had called in first, so she did not know
that I was safe. Oh God, what if she had stayed around for me and died
because of it?
I choked this thought back quickly, it
threatened my very sanity. No, Joan was a very smart woman, she would
have gotten away. There was no way in the madness for two people to
find each other. We owed it to each other to get to safety and then
connect through a common phone line, her parents. God could not have
delivered her miraculously from the building (I think I still did not
know about the time lag) only to take her life afterwards.
The dust was gradually clearing, the sun was shining through again, and
the phones were not working at all, so I decided to take my chances in
the street. I wanted to get uptown to my in-laws so I could be with
them while we waited for word from Joan. I took off my shirt and
wrapped it around my face and headed east. There was an ambulance
handing out dust masks so I got one of those, put my shirt back on and
headed up with the other survivors. Just a few blocks north, as I
crossed under the Brooklyn Bridge, the air cleared enough to remove the
mask and the sky was a clear perfect blue. People were walking over the
bridge to Brooklyn, people were flowing uptown, everyone was being led
out of downtown.
As I walked along I saw several people from the 72nd
floor. It seemed many of them had made it out (in fact almost all
did). I came upon some people from 73. I spoke briefly with each group
I came upon, but it was a real struggle to keep composed and act
normal. I walk fast, and I would quickly leave them behind, telling
them I had to find what had happened to my wife.
On
Canal Street, while walking with a co-worker named Sam, we got stuck for
a minute while traffic passed ahead of us. I had a clear view of the
remaining tower, the one I had worked in. As I watched in disbelief the
building chose that moment to fall. It crumbled, appearing to melt down
from the top. It looked like a very controlled demolition, and I began
to theorize that the elevator workers had planted bombs, but I heard
enough since then to realize that the building was actually designed to
fall that way if the worst happened.
As an Engineer I was so impressed and proud that they had incredibly
planned for what had happened. So many lives saved because of such
careful, well-thought out design. When I later found out that a 767
loaded with fuel had hit the building I was even more impressed. The
impact was so minor, the swaying of the building so much less than one
would have expected, the explosion so muffled, that I could not believe
how well the building was constructed. The fact that my client, the
Port Authority, had been responsible for the design and construction
made me even more proud. Were it not for this we all would be dead
today. The buildings gave us a lot of time to get out. It was like
they valiantly held themselves together as long as possible so the
greatest number of people got out, and then expired in a way that harmed
the least number of people in their passing.
But as I walked uptown from Canal Street my mind was not on the
buildings, it was on my wife. At least I knew she got out of the
building. The odds were now so much better that I was very optimistic,
but of course I needed certainty. I kept trying my cell, I waited on
several corners and tried by pay phone, and I went in a few buildings to
use their phones, trying to get word on Joan. A few times I got through
to her sister and Joan had not called. My hopes were sinking again.
Somewhere in Soho I came upon a church. I was staying on the side
streets, away from the crush of people on the main avenues. I went into
the cool, empty, beautiful church and kneeled in a pew in the back. I
had stopped going to church years ago but my belief in God had never
wavered, I just worshipped Him in my own way. I prayed for Joan’s
safety, but asked that if in fact it was her time to go that God take
her to heaven, where one day we might be reunited. I promised to be a
better Catholic, and to devote my life to helping others. I promised to
change for the better, to learn the lesson this time that I somehow
forgot after the San Francisco Earthquake.
Finally, around 30th Street I got through on my cell phone
and heard that Joan had called in and was ok, still no word on where she
was but she was definitely ok. Again I fell back, unable to stand at the
strong emotion that gripped me. Again I was unable to speak, to get out
words, again the joy engulfed me and made me whole.
There were still a few hours of uncertainty ahead, because I still had
not spoken to her and no one knew where she was. Later, Joan told me
that she was in her office on 91 and heard a crack like thunder.
She looked out her window and saw the fireball from the North Tower and
felt an incredible heat. The heat was so intense that she left
her office to call me, and when she did not get through she grabbed her
pocketbook and headed for the elevator. It took her and many co-workers
to the 78th Floor, where they had to wait for another
elevator. The scene was relatively calm, it was the other building that
had a problem, but they were evacuating all the same. Remember that
there was only 18 minutes before the next plane hit, so every second
counted. Joan spoke to a few people she knew. Horribly, some of these
people apparently returned back up to their offices and died when the
plane hit. A friend was on the phone with his wife and she was
watching on TV when the plane struck.
Joan however stayed focused, and got in the first elevator that came,
which unfortunately only went down to the 44th floor.
Co-workers that waited and got in one that went all the way down were a
few blocks away when the 2nd plane hit. Unfortunately, Joan
was still walking down the stairs from the 44th floor and had
made it to the 10th floor when the plane hit and the building
swayed. It was calm on the stairs till then, but at that moment people
gasped, a few screamed. Most people miraculously stayed calm however,
and filed down the remaining stairs and out. She told me there were
times when slower moving people held up the line, but still no one
trampled them or shoved them out of the way. No one realized how much
danger they were in, no one knew the building would fall down.
When Joan got to the mezzanine level she did not see the carnage in the
plaza. I did not either but my friends described a horrible scene of
body parts and human organs. When she got to the mall the sprinklers had
not yet gone off, the floor was not flooded, nothing. She had actually
got out before me because she used the elevator.
Unfortunately, Joan did what I feared most, she stayed around the
building looking for me. She asked a policeman where the people from
the north tower were coming out. She tried every phone but they would
not work, her cell phone was worthless. She didn’t know if I was alive
or dead.
The scene was calm enough that a few friends stayed with her. They went
to an ATM so her friend could get some cash (survival training). It was
there at Citibank that she finally got a call through, letting her
mother know she was alive, checking on me, and leaving a message at her
sister’s office (who was outside a seminar downtown laying on the
sidewalk screaming because she saw the plane hit Joan’s building). She
didn’t get the message until Thursday, when she returned to work.
Joan
and the other South Tower survivors she was with then actually went to a
coffee shop to get something to drink, and were in the Starbucks just a
few blocks away when the ground shook, the building trembled, and the
lights flickered on and off. People began screaming and other in the
street ran by the building, (think of Godzilla movies). The South
Tower, the second one hit and the first to fall, had collapsed,
imploding upon itself. The dust cloud went east, up the block I had
taken refuge on, not North, where Joan went. Joan and her friend got
out of the building and walked uptown. Some time later while sitting on
a hydrant next to a building she looked back, saw the smoke clear, and
saw the antennae on the roof of the north tower sink down. Still she
did not know my fate.
A
lot of people want to know how we reconnected. I walked way up to the
90s, joined my in laws around noon or 1pm, and waited for Joan to get
there or call in. She had already called in twice, but despite that, we
began worrying again when so much time went by, because it turns out
that she spoke to someone at my other sister-in law’s job and we were
not sure if it was before or after the buildings fell. Finally around
2pm she called again, and I ran out down 2nd Ave to meet her,
ultimately joining up on 66th Street. Words cannot describe
how good we both felt to see each other.
Joan
and I have a deep and true love that has gotten stronger and stronger
since we met New Years Eve in 1980/81. Our souls have merged and it is
hard to imagine life without her. Today we are even closer, maintaining
more constant personal contact, as though by holding her hand I can
prevent evil forces from taking her away. Today will be our first day
apart since the attack, and I am filled with great anxiety, but like all
Americans we are putting fear behind us and re-building our life.
So what are we left with, in the aftermath of this great tragedy?
Thousands of people are dead, our world stands poised on the edge of
senseless destruction, and survivors like Joan and I fear a repeat
performance. If that were all, the Taliban would have succeeded, and
struck a victory. Instead, in that dramatic morning, because of a cruel
and inhuman act, America was given back its humanity. Churches are full,
God Bless America is sung at all gatherings of people I have attended,
and we are discussing world events more than our personal lives. People
have donated time, money, clothes, their blood, and most important of
all, their lives, to help others through this difficult time. We are
taking the first steps toward being a better people.
Unfortunately, there are always ignorant and cruel people in every
culture, and some Americans are senselessly attacking innocent people
from other countries who live in America. Typically, this happens quite
far from the place where the attack took place, and is perpetrated by
those who lost no one or nothing in the attack, except their feeling of
security. At Ground Zero we feel only numbness, and an intense feeling
of vulnerability. We want only a place of safety.
When we
ran that day down the stairs we thought we were safe until a plane hit
the building while we were still inside. When we miraculously got to
the downstairs we thought we were safe until the first building fell,
and when we were not hit by debris we heaved a sigh of relief, only to
have our lungs filled with dust from the pulverized building. Now
although some of us are back home in our own beds, we still did not find
a place of safety, because of world events. My heart pounds and the
adrenaline flows when it is not needed and I find it hard to eat. But
still we get up, shower and dress and go about our everyday lives, and
try to find the greater meaning. I for one will try to find it in
helping others every day, in being kinder and more patient, in
re-establishing my ties with God, and in sending out messages of hope
like this so my worst fears do not come true
|